• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

SozTheo

Sozialwissenschaftliche Theorien

  • Criminology
  • Theories of crime
    • Anomie/ strain theories
    • Biological theories of crime
    • Career/ Development/ Life-Course
    • Conflict-oriented theories of crime
    • Control
    • Culture/ Emotions/ Situations
    • Learning/ Subculture
    • Rational Choice
    • Sanctioning
    • Social Disorganization
  • Sociology
  • Links
Sie befinden sich hier: Home / Theories of crime / Conflict-oriented theories of crime / Outsiders (Becker)

Outsiders (Becker)

12. April 2019 | zuletzt aktualisiert am 18. April 2022 von Christian Wickert

In his book Outsiders, published in 1963, Becker describes the processes by which certain behaviors are criminalized. So-called moral entrepreneurs attempt to eliminate an evil they perceive by creating and enforcing norms. The groups that continue to practice the newly criminalized behaviour thus become outsiders. Through these processes, self-fulfilling prophecies become active, according to Becker.

Inhaltsverzeichnis

Toggle
  • Main proponent
  • Theory
  • Implication for criminal policy
  • Critical appreciation & relevance
  • Literature
  • Further Information
    • Video
    • Example of application

Main proponent

Howard S. Becker

Theory

Becker describes in his theory how behaviour is criminalized. Important for him is the basic assumption that crime is a product of attributions. For Becker, this process is selective at two different levels:

  1. Which behaviors are criminalized is selective,
  2. and existing norms are selectively enforced.

This means that not all breaches of the norm are punished in the same way. For someone to become a deviator, his behaviour must violate an existing norm and this norm must also be enforced (see Table 1). Becker is particularly interested in the question of how to determine which behaviors are pursued and which are not.

Table 1: Types of deviant behaviour

Obedient Behavior Rule-breaking Behavior
perceived as deviant falsely accused pure deviant
not perceived as deviant conforming secret deviant

(Becker 1963: 20)

In “Outsiders”, Becker examines marijuana users and the attempts of moral entrepreneurs to criminalize this consumption.
For Becker, labeling a certain activity as deviant has two different functions. There is a justification for moral entrepreneurs to take action against this behaviour and to condemn it morally. For the outsiders, however, the label has the function of creating identity. An identification with the attribution “deviant” takes place, whereby secondary deviance arises (for the concept of secondary deviance see here). Becker describes this process as a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Probably the most concise summary of the process of criminalizing social deviators is given by Becker himself. The much quoted saying is:

The deviant is one to whom that label has successfully been applied; deviant behavior is behavior that people so label.
(Becker, 1963: 9)

Implication for criminal policy

In his 1963 study on outsiders, Becker takes a sociological and criminological perspective on deviance, which was later named and further developed by criminologists such as Edwin Lemert in the USA and Fritz Sack in Germany as a labelling approach. The perspective of the criminalization of social groups clearly distinguishes itself from the 1963 predominant idea of a pathological type of criminal, whose behavior is explained, for example, by his belonging to a deviant subculture (see: Subculture Theory according to Cohen). Becker is thus considered (alongside Matza) to be one of the pioneers of a paradigm shift in criminology and a pioneer of critical criminology.

Critical appreciation & relevance

Although Howard S. Becker does not regard himself as a criminologist, but as a sociologist and music ethnologist, his book “Outsiders” is still regarded today as one of the most influential and frequently quoted works of deviant sociology and criminology. One criticism of the work is that by shifting the perspective to criminalization (instead of the etiological view of the origin of criminal behavior) a romanticization and trivialization of crimes would take place. Becker addresses this critique in the essay “Whose Side Are We On?” (1967).

Literature

  • Becker, Howard S. (1963): Outsiders : studies in the sociology of deviance. New York [u.a.]: Free Press of Glencoe [u.a.].
  • Becker, Howard S. (1967): Whose Side Are We On? In: Social Problems, 14(3), S. 239-247.

Further Information

  • Howard S. Becker’s personal web page

Video

[Youtube Direktlink]

Example of application

Tonträgerkennzeichnung Parental Advisory labelIn his work on the Parents’ Music Resource Center, cultural scientist Claude Chastagner gives a vivid example of a successful “moral crusade” in Becker’s sense. Chastagner explains how a number of influential US-American politicians’ wives (the so called Washington wives) succeeded in exerting influence on the music industry, so that it was forced to use a Parental Advisory sticker on sound carriers to point out song lyrics that might be harmful to young people.

  • Chastagner, Claude (1999) The Parents’ Music Resource Center: From Information to Censorship. In: Popular Music. Band 18, Nr. 2, S. 179–192. Online available under: https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-00176147/document

Teile diesen Beitrag
  • teilen 
  • teilen 
  • teilen 
  • E-Mail 

Verwandte Beiträge:

  • Kriminalitaetstheorien
    Theories of crime
  • Germantown Avenue in Philadelphia
    Code of the Street (Anderson)
  • Titelbild für Ausführungen zu Jack Katz' Seductions of Crime
    Seductions of Crime (Katz)

Kategorie: Theories of Crime Tags: 1963, deviance, Exklusion, labelling, Lebenslauf, Lemert, micro/macro, outsider, Outsider, punitive, punitive, radical, sanctioning, secondary deviance, sociology, Soziale Identität, Soziale Rollen, subculture, Subculture, theories of crime, USA

Primary Sidebar

Lessons

  • Marxist Theory of Crime
    Based on Karl Marx
  • Feminist Criminology
    Various Authors
  • Power-Control Theory
    John Hagan
  • Labelling Approach
    Overview
  • Primary & Secondary Deviance
    Edwin M. Lemert
  • Outsiders
    Howard S. Becker
  • Radical Labelling Approach
    Fritz Sack

Quiz zu herrschafts- und gesellschaftskritischen Kriminalitätstheorien

Footer

About SozTheo

SozTheo is a collection of information and resources aimed at all readers interested in sociology and criminology. SozTheo was created as a private page by Prof. Dr. Christian Wickert, lecturer in sociology and criminology at the University of Applied Sciences for Police and Public Administration in North Rhine-Westphalia (HSPV NRW). The contributions and linked articles available here do not necessarily reflect the official opinion, attitude or curricula of the HSPV NRW.

Impressum & Kontakt

  • About me

Partnerseiten

Criminologia – Kriminologie-Blog

Krimpedia

  • English
    • Deutsch (German)

Spread the word


Teile diesen Beitrag
  • teilen 
  • teilen 
  • teilen 
  • E-Mail 

© 2025 · SozTheo · Admin